Cookie Monster Cookies: 3 Kinds of Chocolate

If you’re looking for a cookie that screams fun, tastes like pure childhood nostalgia, and is absolutely loaded with chocolate, then you’ve found your new favorite obsession: Cookie Monster Cookies. Seriously, these aren’t just any blue cookies; they are huge, packed with three kinds of chocolate, and stuffed with crunchy cookies. That’s the secret to that amazing texture!

Hi there, I’m Anna Kowalska, and here I share tried-and-true homemade recipes that you and your family will love. Everything, especially these dazzling blue treats, is made with heart and flavor. I believe baking should bring joy, not stress. My kitchen is where recipes get tested until they are absolutely perfect—reliable, delicious, and made with love. These Cookie Monster Cookies are the result of wanting that perfect balance between a soft, chewy base and a fantastic crunch in every single bite.

Gathering What You Need for Cookie Monster Cookies

Alright, let’s talk supplies! Making these incredible, overloaded Cookie Monster Cookies requires a bit of an arsenal, but trust me, every single ingredient plays a vital role in that signature texture and flavor profile. We aren’t just throwing chocolate in here; we are layering textures! Make sure your butter is nice and soft—room temperature is key for that initial creaming step. Also, don’t skimp on the blue coloring; we want that vibrant, happy hue!

Take a peek below to make sure you have everything ready to go before you even think about turning on the mixer. Having this all laid out makes the whole process so much smoother, I promise.

Ingredient List for Cookie Monster Cookies

This list looks long, but it’s just a lot of delicious additions! The mix-ins are what make these Cookie Monster Cookies truly special.

• 1 cup butter (make sure it’s at room temperature—not melted!)
• 1 cup light brown sugar packed (that molasses flavor is crucial)
• ¾ cup granulated sugar
• 2 large eggs
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
• Blue food coloring (enough to get that bright monster blue!)
• 1 teaspoon salt
• 2 teaspoons baking powder
• 3 cups flour (all-purpose is perfect)
• ¾ cup semisweet chocolate chips
• ½ cup white chocolate chips
• ¾ cup chopped Oreos (I usually use about 10 cookies)
• ¾ cup chopped crispy chocolate chip cookies (Famous Amos, mini Chips Ahoy—go for crunch!)
• ¾ cup milk chocolate discs or chunks of milk chocolate bar (These are our gooey centers!)
• Extra chocolate chips, white chips, Oreos, and crispy cookies for topping

Essential Equipment for Baking

You don’t need anything fancy, but having the right tools sure helps!

• A stand mixer or a good handheld electric mixer (your arm will thank you!)
• Large mixing bowls
• Measuring cups and spoons (measure that flour correctly!)
• A rubber spatula for scraping down the sides
• Baking sheets (two is ideal so you can bake in batches)
• Parchment paper or silicone baking mats
• A cookie scoop or two tablespoons for consistent sizing

Step-by-Step Guide to Perfect Cookie Monster Cookies

This is where the magic happens, folks! Follow these steps closely, especially the timing, and you won’t end up with flat, sad cookies. We’re aiming for thick, chewy, and wonderfully blue. Preheat that oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit right now so it’s ready when you are.

Preparing the Dough Base

First things first, we need the structure right. In your mixing bowl, combine that room temperature butter with both the light brown sugar and the granulated sugar. You need to cream these together for exactly 1 minute. Don’t rush this—we’re incorporating air!

Next, drop in your two large eggs and the vanilla. Now, this is important: keep creaming for a full 3 minutes after adding the eggs. The mixture should look noticeably lighter in color, almost pale yellow, and definitely fluffy. If it looks dense, keep mixing; that fluffiness is what keeps these cookies thick later on.

Coloring and Mixing Dry Ingredients for Cookie Monster Cookies

Time for the fun part: color! Add your blue food coloring now. I usually start with a few drops and mix until I get a vibrant, happy shade of blue that screams Cookie Monster Cookies. You want it bright because things tend to mute a little when baked.

In a separate bowl, whisk together your flour, salt, and baking powder. Now, add these dry ingredients to your blue butter mixture. Mix only until you see no more streaks of white flour remaining. I mean it—stop the mixer! Overmixing the flour develops gluten, and we want soft, not tough, cookies.

Folding in the Flavor Overload

This is where we load them up! Grab your semisweet chips, white chocolate chips, chopped Oreos, and those crispy chocolate chip cookies. Use a sturdy spatula to gently fold all of this goodness into the blue dough. You want everything evenly distributed throughout the batter, but fold gently so you don’t knock out all that air we just whipped in.

Shaping and Topping Your Cookie Monster Cookies

If your dough feels super soft right now, pop it in the fridge for about 30 minutes. Seriously, a quick chill helps these thick Cookie Monster Cookies hold their shape. Once chilled (or if you skipped the chill), take about two tablespoons of dough and flatten it in your hand. Place 2 or 3 of those solid chocolate discs right in the center. This is my favorite trick!

Carefully wrap the dough edges up and around those chocolate pieces, sealing them completely. Top that ball with a second, smaller scoop of dough to fully encase the center. Then, press a few extra chocolate chips, Oreos, and crispy cookie bits right on top for that overloaded look.

Baking Times and Cooling Protocol

Place your dough balls on a lined baking sheet, leaving plenty of space between them—they spread! Bake them in your preheated 350-degree oven for 10 to 12 minutes. You’ll know they are done when the edges are set but the very center still looks slightly soft. Resist the urge to pull them out early!

This next part is crucial for texture: let them cool right there on the hot baking sheet for 5 full minutes. They firm up during this resting time. After 5 minutes, gently move them over to a wire rack to finish cooling completely.

Tips for Achieving Expert-Level Cookie Monster Cookies

You’ve got the recipe, but let me give you the inside scoop on making these the absolute best Cookie Monster Cookies they can be. It all comes down to managing texture. Remember how I mentioned the crunchy cookie mix-ins? Don’t just throw any brand in there!

If you want that perfect snap, use Famous Amos—they crumble just right. Mini Chips Ahoy are a close second. Full-sized ones can sometimes be too tough once baked into the cookie matrix. Also, resist the temptation to skip the chilling step if your dough feels soft after mixing in all those goodies. Chilling prevents them from spreading into thin blue pancakes, which ruins the whole overloaded effect we’re going for.

Finally, when you’re topping them, be generous with the extra mix-ins on the surface. This ensures you get that visual pop of color and texture right away, making your Cookie Monster Cookies look totally irresistible when they come out of the oven!

Quick Answers About Your Cookie Monster Cookies

I get so many questions after people try this recipe for the first time, and honestly, that’s the best part! It means you’re baking! Here are the things I hear most often when readers are tackling their first batch of these amazing Cookie Monster Cookies.

What makes these Cookie Monster Cookies blue?

It’s all about the food coloring, pure and simple! We don’t rely on any natural ingredient to give us that signature bright blue. You’ll want to use a good quality gel food coloring if you can find it, as it gives you that intense color without adding too much extra liquid to the dough, which could mess up our texture. Start with a few drops and mix until you’re happy with the shade. We’re going for fun, vibrant blue!

Can I substitute any of the crunchy cookie mix-ins?

Absolutely, you can substitute, but I highly recommend following the texture notes if you want that perfect chew-to-crunch ratio in your Cookie Monster Cookies. I found that Famous Amos gave the best texture because they are smaller and bake up just right. Mini Chips Ahoy work well too. If you use full-sized Chips Ahoy, I’d chop them up quite small so they distribute evenly. The goal is crunch, not huge, hard chunks!

How do I keep the chocolate centers gooey?

This is all about technique when shaping the dough. Remember, we are creating a chocolate bomb in the middle! Take your first scoop of dough, flatten it, place the chocolate discs right in the center, and then completely seal the dough around those discs—like you’re wrapping a little present. Then, cover that whole package with a second, smaller scoop of dough. If the chocolate is fully encased, it melts beautifully inside without leaking out onto the pan and burning!

Storing and Enjoying Your Homemade Cookies

Now that you’ve baked two dozen of the most magnificent, overloaded Cookie Monster Cookies known to humankind, you need to know how to keep them tasting fresh for days. These cookies are loaded with so much goodness—especially those chunky bits of chocolate and cookie—that they can sometimes get a little soft if stored improperly.

The good news is that these hold up really well on the counter, provided you keep them airtight. The key is making sure they are fully cooled before you even think about putting them in a container. Warm cookies create steam, and steam equals sad, soggy cookies. Nobody wants that!

Storage and Reheating Instructions for Cookie Monster Cookies

For the best texture and flavor, I always store my Cookie Monster Cookies at room temperature. Keep them in a sturdy, airtight container. If you stack them, use a piece of parchment paper between the layers to prevent the toppings from sticking together. They should stay perfectly soft and chewy for about 4 or 5 days this way.

If you happen to have leftovers past that, they freeze beautifully! Lay them on a tray until solid, then move them to a freezer-safe bag for up to three months. When you need a treat, you don’t even need to thaw them completely. Just pop one in the microwave for about 10 to 15 seconds. That quick zap brings back the gooey melted center, and they taste almost freshly baked!

Storage Method	Duration	Best For
Airtight Container (Room Temp)	4–5 Days	Chewy texture
Airtight Container (Refrigerator)	Up to 1 Week	Slightly firmer texture
Freezer (Sealed Bag)	Up to 3 Months	Long-term freshness

Sharing Your Blue Baking Success

I just know you’re going to have a blast making these cookies! They are so much fun to eat, and I love seeing your creations. Once you pull these beauties out of the oven, snap a picture and tell me how they turned out! Did your kids love the blue color? Drop a comment below and let me know how many you managed to save for later!

Print